Hope for Healing: Dr. Stracks & Michelle (Grim) Archer

Video: Watch the full session here →https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KLAHa2Zgt10


Dr. John Stracks: Welcome. I am Dr. John Stracks, and many of you probably know me. I am here with my colleague Michelle Grim, who is a plastic surgery physician assistant and yoga instructor in Durango, Colorado, and we are thrilled to be joining you this evening to talk about mind-body medicine.

For those of you who don't know me, I am a physician in Chicago, Illinois, who has been interested in mind-body medicine my entire career, from the time I started medical school in 2001 until I joined the faculty at Northwestern in Chicago in 2009 and then opened my own practice in 2017. This area of medicine has always been my favorite area to practice in, and I opened my own practice to expand people's access to this type of medicine. I provide individual consultations, usually in my office, and now with COVID I provide them remotely. I also have my own classes and groups, and I give ongoing support to people who are working in this area.

This broadcast tonight is part of the Hope for Healing series that we started about a month ago, when we were in the midst of COVID thinking about what we could do to help people during this time. We started these every-other-week broadcasts to bring more information about what we do and how we work in this field, and to bring a variety of perspectives on how medical professionals provide support in this area.

Michelle, as I said, is a plastic surgery physician assistant, yoga instructor, and yoga therapist. She and I have been colleagues for four or five years now. We collaborated when she lived in Chicago and have done some workshops together in this area. Some of you may also know her as a Curable group leader, and in fact she has a group that she's leading tonight at 5 o'clock Mountain time, so she's going to hop off the call at about 10 to 5 her time. I will stay on to continue to answer questions until about 5:15 Mountain time, 6:15 Central time.

Michelle has been a great ambassador for mind-body medicine, and she has a little different take on how this all works than I do and some of the other physicians who work in this field, which is why I wanted her to be able to talk to you this evening. In some ways, because of her yoga background, for her it's almost more body-mind medicine than mind-body medicine. We'll talk a little about the difference this evening.

I have been convinced for quite some time that we spend a lot of time in this area talking about how the mind influences the body, but I have known for a long time that the body influences the mind as well. When we think about the kinds of treatments that are helpful for people, I think that learning how to work in the body to influence the mind is the next frontier in this field. Michelle, I'm super glad that you could join me this evening. Did I leave out anything about you that people should know?

Michelle Grim: That was a wonderful introduction, thank you. I don't know if I could have said it as well. I'm really honored to be here, and I think Dr. Stracks captured this well: I've been in this world for a little while, but I've been coming from a slightly different perspective. I tend to focus on the body and how it can influence healing a little more than we'll often find in the mind-body world. That's been an area of passion for me since I first experienced yoga. I wanted to know how it worked, and it led me down this path. Of course, like so many of us, I also have my own personal journey with pain, so it was very applicable when I started to experience yoga healing my pain that I would get involved in this realm and dive deeply into it, looking for knowledge. So thanks so much for the intro.

Dr. Stracks: You're welcome. I love telling people that you're a plastic surgery physician assistant and yoga instructor. Can you talk a little about how each of those got started?

From Plastic Surgery Physician Assistant to Yoga Therapist

Michelle Grim: Sure. I never thought I would be in plastics, first of all, but I knew I wanted to be in medicine, and I thought maybe I'd be a doctor. Actually, I had some health issues in college and noticed that I never took care of myself because I was focusing so much on my studies. The health issues I had kind of freaked me out and made me reconsider what I was doing, so I walked away from medicine, but I never could walk away from it in my heart. I became a PA because it was a little more flexible and a shorter path, quite a bit shorter.

While I was training, I wanted to work with women, and I decided to do a training with a plastic surgeon because he worked a lot with women with breast cancer. I just fell in love with plastic surgery, mostly breast reconstruction, so that's what I've been doing for the last 11 years. Recently I added in orthopedics, which has been interesting, but a great way to talk to people about pain. That's how I got into plastics.

Then I couldn't really deny these experiences I'd had with yoga. About the same time I started being a PA in plastics, I started a yoga teacher training. It wasn't until I was pretty far into yoga that I started having some other health issues and noticed that yoga helped so much, and that's how I ended up training as a yoga therapist. I just keep diving a little more and a little more.

Dr. Stracks: I was just doing the math. You started at Northwestern in 2009?

Michelle Grim: I did.

Dr. Stracks: That's the same year I started there too. I don't think we really recognized that. Anyway, you just said you'd had some of your own pain issues that yoga helped you work out. Would you feel comfortable telling people a little about what that was like and how you were able to work your way out of it?

Michelle's Story: Healing Chronic Pain Through Yoga

Michelle Grim: For sure. It's interesting when you get further into this world: you start to notice all the other things that were probably going along with your mind-body syndrome. It's not just pain, but the first thing that caught my attention for sure was pain. In deciding what I wanted to say when we were discussing this, I had to think back and really remember.

I went into my first doctor's visit because I was a runner. I used to run to Northwestern from my home. I used to run commutes.

Dr. Stracks: Where did you live?

Michelle Grim: I lived in the South Loop, so it was about a three-mile run. I would run to work and run home, and I was having just the most knee pain. I went to a doctor and said, “Hey, I'm a runner, I'm really concerned about my knees. We have to have them be okay.” He said, “I'm not really concerned about your knee. What's going on with your ankle?” I said, “Oh, I just have tendonitis there, but I never stopped running, so it just doesn't go away.” He said, “I'm not sure that's what's happening,” and it initiated this huge workup, which found a bunch of things that no one really knew were causing my pain.

What happened during that time is that I also stopped running, because people were telling me it was a bad idea to run, and my pain didn't go away. Then I really started freaking out: I thought this would go away if I wasn't running. That set me off into about three years of persistent pain. I was hobbling every morning and hobbling by the end of the day. I changed all my activity. I completely stopped running and moved to swimming. I tried to find things, but I wrote off so many things that I just couldn't do anymore. I saw four different doctors and got four different recommendations for what should be done, because no one really knew what would help me. I went to a bunch of physical therapists. I was on and off in a boot for probably about a year, doing different treatments for my ankle without any resolution of my symptoms. The more time I spent doing that, the more I kept getting answers of “we don't know what's going on.” I don't think I even heard “sorry.”

Dr. Stracks: You and I have talked about this before, and I've heard you tell this story before. Do you think the journey through the medical system made it that much worse? I mean, you weren't in that much pain when you first went to the physician, right?

Michelle Grim: Yes, I think it made it way worse. Knowing what I know now, I can look back and see all the catastrophic thoughts that came to me after seeing doctors. I had a doctor tell me all the things that were going to be hardest for me, and I thought, “I'm never going to be able to do those things again.” I went spiraling into a lot of fear about my life being taken away from me. That's what it felt like: the things that I loved doing, I kept hearing that they were not going to be possible for me.

Since you asked that, I recently decided maybe I should check in on what's happening in my ankle and see a doctor, even just having a curbside consult, because I work in orthopedics and can ask a doctor that I work with. I totally had a pain flare. So moving through the system really was super hard for me and definitely amplified my pain experience. That was a big part of what I got through as I've been looking at it more.

During that period of my life I came up with a bunch of “nevers.” I'm never going to be able to backpack again. I'm never going to be able to run again. I might not even be able to be in the OR anymore, because I can barely handle standing, it hurts so bad. I would have my foot up on a chair while I was operating so I could be off it. It was hard to watch that continue to almost escalate exponentially and have everyone tell me, “There's just nothing we can do for that, it's just going to keep getting worse.” That's the message I kept hearing from my providers.

Interestingly, during that time, about a year and a half into this journey, I also started having unexplained dizziness. Similarly, I was totally thrown for a loop, had a huge workup, and no one could find anything wrong with me. I also had IBS symptoms during that time.

Dr. Stracks: Irritable bowel.

Michelle Grim: Yes. When you look back, you can see so much of it building on top of everything else.

What really changed it for me, and I feel very lucky for this experience, is that because of all of these troubles I wasn't practicing yoga anymore. I had started to teach a really subtle type of yoga called yoga nidra, which essentially just involves lying on the floor. If someone had asked me about that when I first started yoga, I would have had no interest. It was not my thing. But all of these troubles meant that was all I could really do in yoga. I taught a yoga nidra class, and I still so vividly remember coming out after teaching it with absolutely no pain in my ankle. I didn't have pain for five days. Even when I tell the story again I get the chills, because it was so noticeable and so astounding. I didn't understand what had just happened, and that's what got me into all of this, looking for more knowledge.

Actually, for those of you out there who know Dr. Stracks, you might know that he also did a training in sensorimotor psychotherapy. That's how I got connected with him: I did that same training, looking for more information on how the mind and body are connected. That was the beginning of my journey, and that's when I really recognized that a lot of the things they're teaching are yoga: mindfulness, becoming embodied. That's what brought me to a training in yoga therapy.

I can't say there was a moment when my pain changed. I had those five pain-free days and then it came back, but very slowly over time it's gotten so much better. For example, I just moved to Colorado, and hiking was one of the things I was told I was never really going to be able to do, or that it would be the hardest thing for me. When I first moved here, I had to post this on social media because I was so happy: I hiked up a mountain and ran down it, and I had no pain. It was just so worth celebrating. So it was a slow process, but overall I started finding that I could do things I didn't think I could do. When I recognized that, I would celebrate it, and then it continued to get better.

Yoga has always been a part of that. The things I was doing along the way were so body-based: body scans, imagining my ankle happy and healthy, slow and mindful movement with my joints. These things were all a part of what was happening during that time, getting back into my body in a way that didn't feel scary. When I did my first meditation with my ankle, it was a dark and scary experience. So I've come back into my body in a safer way, and that's really what yoga has given me for my experience with healing through this path.

Yoga Therapy for Trauma, Pain, and Nervous System Regulation

Dr. Stracks: You and I met because I had done training in sensorimotor psychotherapy and you had done training too, and you have since gone on and done a variety of trainings in yoga therapy, correct?

Michelle Grim: Yes. In yoga therapy we're looking a lot at nervous system regulation, but the part that really got me the most was learning about yoga therapy for trauma and yoga therapy for pain. Those things combine so well because we can look at our nervous system states and how the body responds, or how bottom-up processing can hijack us a little bit. For trauma, yoga is so good at addressing that. We can work on the breath, we can work on body tension, and we can work on observing that mindfully, and those are all skills that are really encouraged in yoga. Yoga offers so many resources. If I'm feeling really anxious, there are breaths that can help with that, and there are practices with your body that can help with that.

Pain is similar. The more we look at the neuroscience of pain, the more we know that pain is really about danger. If we can decrease that sense of danger in the body, or in the emotions, or in the thoughts, and a lot of what yoga looks at is the body, then we can really decrease that danger signal and decrease pain. So it all came together nicely.

Top-Down vs. Bottom-Up Strategies for Healing Pain

Dr. Stracks: You and I have talked extensively about the variety of ways that people can learn to heal pain, and we often divide them into top-down and bottom-up. Top-down is a lot of what I traditionally have done, along with my colleagues Dr. Schubiner, Dr. Hanscom, and Dr. Clarke, who people will hear from in a couple of weeks. We're trained as physicians in very cerebral ways, so we encourage people to learn about pain, which I know you do as well, and then to figure out ways that we can use the power of our minds to understand better what's going on in our bodies, so we can think about pain differently. We can journal and see what comes up as we write. We can visualize the pain in a different way. We can learn how to stop catastrophic thinking, which is one of the things you were talking about, what happened to you in the midst of seeing all these physicians who didn't have answers and who told you...

I get so upset when I hear providers telling patients things like “you'll never walk normally again” or “you'll never do the things that you want to do.” I had a guest in my own class last night who said that when he was 40 and threw his back out for the first time, the first physician said to him, “All right, no more basketball, no more golf, no more tennis.” He's like, what? It's just so disappointing.

So these top-down strategies are frequently how I explain ways to improve pain to people. Tell us how you think about the more bottom-up strategies, both how you learned about those and how you have been starting to use them with your clients.

Michelle Grim: Bottom-up, if you haven't heard that term before, is more about how you perceive or sense what's happening in the body: how you take in information through the senses, like a body posture you might hold or some movement. Those things are hugely influential. Your nervous system doesn't really know what's going on outside of you except through your senses, and especially when there's potential danger, those things often move really quickly to help you re-establish safety. Information from the senses can, like I said earlier, almost hijack the next level up: “I'm sensing there's some danger,” and then my emotions feel fear, and then my thoughts are “I've got to get out of here.”

The way I've started to conceptualize pain, and using the body for treatments in pain, is learning ways that we can use the body to cultivate a sense of safety. These are things we often don't realize are happening, so the first step is usually just becoming aware of what's happening in the body. Even today, I was driving to work and realized I had forgotten my headphones for this call, and I had to drive back and I was going to be late to work. I noticed that I tensed up in my chest and in my low ribs, and I could feel this anxiety there. That often happens without you even noticing, but it's contributing so much to how your brain is perceiving whether you're in danger or not.

That's the way in: first helping people become aware of what's happening in their body in a way that feels safe, and then realizing that the body can be a resource. We can change the body tension, we can regulate the breath, we can find movement, and we can choose movement in ways that feel safe. All these things can then really influence the brain, emotions, and thoughts. If you've ever taken a power pose, if I stand this way it might feel different than if I'm standing this way. That's how I use this information, and I use the path of yoga because yoga offers so many skills in changing the body and breath to help people look at and heal pain.

Creating a Sense of Safety in the Body: Polyvagal Theory and Trauma

Dr. Stracks: We've talked a lot about trauma and how trauma will show up in the body. When I started my sensorimotor psychotherapy training, it was specifically to get more information about how to treat trauma, because it's not something that's taught well in medical school, and probably not in PA school either. I hear you talk a lot about creating safety in the body. What are ways that you work with people from a trauma perspective, and ways to create that sense of safety? How do you think about that when you're working with people?

Michelle Grim: A lot of the work that we look at through yoga therapy is based on the polyvagal theory. The polyvagal theory explains how, when we're experiencing a threat, we activate and we're ready to fight or flee. If it completely overwhelms us, we go even further and drop into collapse. A lot of what I do using the body is figuring out what your predominant pattern is, where you go, and then we try to meet you there and move you back into safety.

Some clients I work with collapse, and then you have to start slow and actually create some activity in the body. This is maybe more the work of a trauma therapist, who would look for your action, your empowering action. I don't do that as much because I'm not a therapist. What I do is try to cultivate the sense of “I can embody my body and be safe, I can get out of this collapse, and I can experience something else.” What that offers is empowerment: realizing that you have the capacity to change your state. Often this feels really startling: I didn't even realize this was happening, and now I can't think straight, or I can't breathe, I'm so anxious, I'm shaking. These things can take people over. In the trauma world we call that being triggered, and that's really the bottom-up hijack. It can feel really powerless because you don't understand what's happening.

We can meet that state and then teach people ways to get back to what I call center. If they've collapsed, we need to activate and then come back down. If someone is really activated, we just need to calm. That's a broad way of explaining it, maybe a little technical, but we can teach people that they can change the state of their body, and that ripples over. You'll see people say, “Now I believe this about myself,” or “I feel capable again,” or “I now feel love or joy,” these higher states of emotion, when we can change the state of the body.

Dr. Stracks: I trained in both level 1 and level 2 of sensorimotor psychotherapy, so I do a little of the trauma work with people. Like you said, that kind of therapy works really nicely with people who are working in mind-body medicine. We're looking for where the tension is held in the body and, oftentimes, as you said, what people wanted to do with that tension that they didn't get a chance to do in the moment. Frequently we'll find people's reactions to try to protect themselves, say if they were in a car accident, a bike accident, or mugged. If you pay enough attention to the subtle cues, you can tell that their bodies got stuck in a certain way. You can start to sense that their body wanted to push out this way or kick away the person who was with them. It can be really helpful to free up some stuck energy, and to free up what feels like pain, which is really that energy stuck with nowhere to go.

Michelle Grim: The thing that's really interesting about trauma is that we know there's a trauma cycle: we recognize a threat, we orient to it, we take action, and then we re-establish safety. If that gets interrupted at any point, it never gets cataloged as done, and our brain holds onto it as “we're still in danger, this isn't complete.” Our understanding of pain has really become that it's a danger meter, so if we're holding something as incomplete and we're still in danger, for sure it contributes. I did a lot of work during my own healing journey with a somatic experiencing therapist, and we completed all kinds of actions. It was so freeing. Something that before felt really scary, and that would make me feel fear or tension in my body even if I just thought about it, lost its charge. I could talk about it. It was still real and it still happened, but it didn't pull me as much. It's a really cool thing to see.

Combining Top-Down and Bottom-Up Approaches for Optimal Healing

Dr. Stracks: Absolutely. You lead some of the Curable discussion groups, so you're involved, as I am, with Curable and all the great things they do with their app. I would say Curable is, for the most part, a top-down method: learning about pain, doing journal writing, and meditation is a little of both. How do you see people who are listening being able to incorporate both directions for optimal healing?

Michelle Grim: Some of the material that came out of how Dr. Sarno started this for us was maybe more suggesting that you're going to overpower the body with your brain. I do believe we have the capacity to do that, but I think the body also has a lot of capacity. The way I generally frame this is, again, as danger: wherever your input is coming from that there's danger, let's work there. If the input is coming in from the body, let's work there. Usually there's a component of each, just as there's going to be an emotional component or a thought-based component.

I've had people have great success going out on a bike ride, which they thought they never could do, and telling themselves they're safe, and they do great.

Dr. Stracks: I know, I've had another client with a similar story, but it always makes me think of you.

Michelle Grim: I've also had people where that doesn't work, and then we look at what's happening. They're riding their bike like this, and I ask, “Can we let the shoulders relax? Can we experience the breath moving as you move your body in this way?” I don't think they're in opposition at all. I do get that question sometimes: “I've always been told that I can just think my way out of this.” I say, okay, your thoughts are important because they contribute to a sense of danger, but so is your body, and so are your emotions. I like to integrate it all, and yoga offers that.

The whole idea with yoga is that we work through the different layers of being. If you're really into yoga, you'll know the Pancha Maya Kosha model, the five-layer model of the five layers of being. We work through the body first, because if your body feels crappy you can't really think well. Then we work through the energetic or breath level, then we start to get into the more subtle layers, like our personality and our knowledge, and then we drop even lower into a deep knowing, which we call the bliss body. We do work with the mind and the personality, but we work with the body a little more first. It gives a model for looking at all those levels and acknowledging how integrated we are. You can't separate these things, though you can separate them to come up with strategies, but ultimately if you work on one, it's going to affect all the other levels. That's what yoga offers in a really beautiful way.

Dr. Stracks: I had a conversation one time with someone who is a direct descendant of Moshe Feldenkrais, who developed the Feldenkrais Method, which ties into a lot of what we've talked about. I was talking with her about this concept of mind-body, and she said, “No, no, that implies that there are two separate things.” She wanted me to understand that there's no separation.

Emotions and the Body: Getting in Touch with Feelings

Emotions are something I talk about regularly, and I know that's a big focus of the Curable groups and the Curable app. How does what you do help people tap into their emotions? A lot of people come to me who grew up in families where emotions weren't really allowed, or were shamed, or were taken away from them. How does the work that you do help people get in better touch with emotions, so that they can both recognize them and even allow themselves to feel them?

Michelle Grim: Because I'm pretty body-based, I tend to think of emotions as a feeling that happens in the body, and then an emotion is our interpretation of that, or the way we color something: “This is important,” and so we have an emotion about it. Body work helps with that. I've seen people become more emotionally aware just by becoming more bodily aware, or by learning ways to augment their body or change their breath.

The other part is that, because I think of emotions as coloring a situation, if something is important you have an emotion that alerts you to it. Many emotions can feel dangerous, because there's something important going on, and usually if something's important it's important to our survival or safety. So it can feel dangerous to feel those feelings. A lot of what I do is cultivating this: Do I feel safe? Can I keep looking at this? Can I relax my body and my breath? Then we just look. Generally, if we become more in tune with the way our body feels, we'll notice emotion more, and once we get more comfortable staying safe and looking at it, we'll get its message. The emotion is trying to tell us something important. What is that? Then you can actually access that message rather than being completely overwhelmed by the feeling.

It's a lot of this work, and, contemplating again how we would talk about it, it's subtle. It's not like I did this one thing and it solved all my problems. That was never the way my path was. It was always very subtle. With practice I'd notice little things were better, and then over time my pain was better, but it's not linear. As a PA, and I wonder if you struggled with this too, Dr. Stracks, I wanted everything to be linear: this is your diagnosis, this is the treatment for that, and now it's solved. It's just not that way with pain. It's too integrated and too complex, so it can't be linear. Each day, different things can contribute to why you might feel danger, which means why you might have more or less pain. Today it could have been that I was late for work. Yesterday it could have been that I just moved to Durango and I'm missing my parents. There's a lot that's constantly ebbing and flowing, so it's just not linear. It's more subtle.

Dr. Stracks: I'm actually a fairly nonlinear person, especially for a physician. Occasionally I'll think about various pathways I could have taken. I'll think, why did I do my residency in Michigan? Oh yeah, we had to pick up our son there, who was born third year of medicine, which is a totally nonlinear concept, but it works for me.

It's interesting, though, because I get asked all the time by people who are on this pathway and not feeling better yet, or feeling a little better. People get really embarrassed that they didn't end their pain in 20 minutes like in the stories they read in books. I spend a lot of time telling people that this is how pain gets better: a little bit at a time, with ups and downs. Part of getting better is understanding that on days when you're feeling worse than you were the day before, it doesn't mean you're all the way back to the beginning. You're just taking a little break. Sometimes I tell people you need that dip in order to get the momentum to get to the next stage.

So I think it's nice for people to hear you talk about how that was what the journey was like. There wasn't any one moment when you recognized you were out of pain. There's a really nice Curable podcast from last month with Laura and Christie Uipi, who used to work at the Pain Psychology Center and now runs United Healthcare's group out in Las Vegas. She had the top five lessons that pain patients will learn, one of which was that there is no moment when you're out of pain. I describe it to people sometimes as waking up one morning and thinking, “Oh, it's a bad day. I haven't had one of these for a really long time,” or “It's a bad day, and it's better than good days used to be.” That I think is a lot more of people's experience than just finding the answer and snapping out of it.

Michelle Grim: The thing I would add to that, and maybe you've found this too, is that when I have down slumps now, which still happen, it's a reminder that I need to practice. Not just practice yoga, though yoga is my path, but there are so many parts of that. It's a reminder to check in: What is it I need? That doesn't mean I do it and my pain goes away immediately, but it means I take care of myself, and overall I'm still going up. Whereas before I would drop into what you said, “I'm back to where I was and this is never going to be okay,” I've started to have a little more softness and flexibility, and now I can regroup: “Okay, I just need to help myself right now.”

Dr. Stracks: Christie actually said in that recent podcast that her body sticks up for her. Even when we bounce, our bodies let us know what we need, and we appreciate that. It's a hard concept to understand when you're first starting, but as you go along and see the results, you start to recognize all this wisdom in the body, even when it's showing up as pain.

Trying Softer: Why “Calm Down” Never Works

In a second I want you to lead us through a short exercise, but I have one more question. We've been talking about this concept of trying softer, which I think about regularly. I was looking at something the other day about panic attacks and how we can't make ourselves relax, because the harder we try to relax, the tenser we get. Do you have thoughts about this concept of trying softer, which a lot of us have been talking about over the last few months?

Michelle Grim: I have maybe two different thoughts on that. One is that my sister sent me a meme, which I've used before, that said, “Never in the history of calming down has anyone ever calmed down by being told to calm down.” It speaks to the idea that trying so hard to tell yourself to relax is the opposite of what you need to be doing, and that's why the body is a nice way in for that.

The other thing, and it brings me back to who you had on last time, I think your last one was with Jessica, is that compassion has been a huge part of being softer. I think it tends to come in naturally when you soften the body and the breath and you stop trying so hard. When I was in a lot of pain, all I could do was yoga nidra and yin yoga, and I would never have done that before. I would have pushed through. I would have said, “I'm going to keep going,” and I couldn't. I just really couldn't, so I learned about softness. I still have to remind myself of that, because I like to go 150 miles an hour, but yoga really encourages softness because it encourages you to show up for what's there instead of pushing yourself into something.

That's more of a therapeutic yoga approach. It's not the popularized yoga where you see people in all these pretzel shapes. It's really about showing up for what is, accepting it, staying, and seeing what happens next. Generally the answer for your healing comes through that process instead of trying to push or pull or grab for an answer. Yoga subtly teaches that by just being in your body, being with your experience, and noticing that it's different today than it was yesterday, and all that comes along with checking in regularly.

Dr. Stracks: It's such a non-Western concept. We've spent so much time in this society pushing and doing and getting there faster and better and further, and that's how we get to a lot of the places we get to. What I find with health issues is that this strategy often doesn't work. People who have used pushing effectively over the course of their lives find themselves in a health situation where it doesn't work, and then they need to find new strategies that are more...

Michelle Grim: That captures my path.

Guided Body and Breath Awareness Practice

Dr. Stracks: Anyway, I'd like you to lead us in a short exercise. Before you do, you need to leave at about 4:55 Mountain time, which is 5:55 Central time. I will stick around a little longer, probably until about 15 minutes after the hour, to continue to answer questions. Some people are listening here on Zoom and some are listening on Facebook. If you're on Zoom and you have questions for us, there's a Q&A button at the bottom of your screen that you can type into. If you're watching on Facebook, you can type your questions into the chat box, and our colleagues from Curable will carry them over here to Zoom so that we can see them. We'll answer as many questions as we can until the time's up, and Michelle will answer them too until she needs to go. Can you lead us through a little activity?

Michelle Grim: As I said throughout this conversation, this can be subtle, and a lot of where we like to start is building awareness. I'll lead you here in a little body and breath awareness practice. Just know that there's no way to do this wrong. This is more of an exploration. There's no good breath and no bad breath. It's really just a way of noticing what's there.

To start this practice, we'll just try to elongate the spine and let your hands rest on your thighs. If you're comfortable, allow your eyes to close or your gaze to drop, so the eyes can relax a little. If you're feeling up in the head, or you find you're thinking about a lot of things, maybe first gently draw your attention to something you can feel in the body, like where you're supported, where your sit bones hit the seat underneath you, or where your back is supported by the chair behind you. Feel the weight of your body supported, and let your body somewhat melt into that support. Feel a sense of being held.

Now gently draw your attention to the breath without changing it at all. Just notice the breath. You might notice a sense of coolness at the nose or mouth when it comes in, or notice the way the chest or belly expands as the breath comes in and then gently recoils as the breath moves out. Take note of the breath again without changing it or judging it. Just notice how it moves.

Again, without changing the breath, we'll start to explore a little movement as if the breath is causing the movement. The next time you inhale, let your chest lift a little, so the chest lifts up and forward through the shoulders, and as you exhale it can drop back to where you started. Let the breath lead this movement, so it feels as though the breath is actually causing the movement to happen, right at the heart space: a gentle lift when the breath moves in and a soft sense of drawing in as the breath moves out. Start to follow the ebb and flow of the body gently moving with the breath. As you continue to breathe in this way, just notice: is the body leading the breath, or is the breath leading the body? Allow the breath to lead the body.

Now start to allow that movement to get a little bigger. Each time you inhale, the chest might lift a little more, and as you exhale there will be a little more drawing in. The back of the body might even round. If you've done cat-cow before, you'll start to experience a little of that: as you inhale you find this little backbend where the heart lifts, and as you exhale you round the spine back behind you. With each breath, maybe allow this movement to get a little bigger, so we really start to feel the way the spine can move, ebbing and flowing forward and back. Remember, there's no way to do this wrong. This is a way for you to explore the body moving with the breath. Let the movement start to get as big as you'd like, exploring how much the spine can move, still moving with the breath. You might even find that your arms want to come wide as the heart lifts, and that's also fine, letting the shoulders open up a little more. Now let this next breath bring this movement as big as you'd like it to be.

Then, over the course of the next five to six breaths, we'll start to let the movement get smaller and smaller, coming back to that subtle movement. Each breath, a little less lift and a little less drawing in. Then, in the next two breaths, we'll come back into stillness, just noticing the breath move, and maybe even that reverberation, that rhythm you can still feel, of the gentle expansion and drawing in, like the memory in your body of that movement as the breath moves. Even here, as you breathe in stillness, your body still expresses this natural expansion and contraction with the breath.

For our last couple of breaths together, maybe bring the hands to the heart: right hand on the heart, left hand over top. Feel the way the palms on the body can feel nurturing and grounding, the hands giving the heart space support, and the heart also gently lifting to fill the palms. When you're ready, we'll let this practice go. Take your time opening your eyes again, and we'll come back together.

Dr. Stracks: Thanks, that was great.

Michelle Grim: You're welcome.

Dr. Stracks: One thing I totally noticed in there, which I knew before, was the slowing down and paying attention. So often pain is so intense and so white-hot, and when we can slow down and take a peek, oftentimes we recognize that it's not as overarchingly horrible as we think it is. And then, what you were saying earlier, when we slow down and look, we can find that there's a lot of meaning in there. I say frequently that the pain is not there to make our lives miserable. The pain is just trying to tell us where we need to go.

I don't get migraines anymore. Since I learned about mind-body medicine 20 years ago I've had one, and it was after a long, long bike ride when I had overhydrated. The first thing I thought when I got it was, “Oh, I know what to do. I'll just tell it to go away.” I did, and I vomited, and I thought, that's not going to work. So I breathed and I watched, and I recognized that it wasn't just an ice pick going through my eye socket. There was a rhythm to it, and over time it flowed out for a little bit longer and wasn't as intense. It came back in, but I had to slow down.

Michelle Grim: Interestingly, we know that output of pain, or that protective measure of tensing up, then becomes an input. It makes it worse. But if we can stop and look, it can often interrupt that. I have had patients, and even myself, have experiences where it's almost like a little blip: oh, it just wasn't there suddenly, and you start to slowly watch it unwind. So slowing down is a great thing for sure.

How to Get Started with Yoga for Pain Relief

Dr. Stracks: I know you need to get to your group in a couple of minutes, and I know some questions are starting to roll in. People here on Zoom are typing them into the Q&A box, and some people on Facebook are asking too. If you have time for just a couple: people have asked how to get started. If you're interested in yoga and haven't really done it before, how would you know how to get started?

Michelle Grim: I think for the average person, going to a more restorative type of yoga is going to encourage more of these skills that really prove helpful. Gaining skills in breath and body awareness, and then how to regulate them, happens a little more in a yin-style or restorative type of class, so that's often a really good place to start. It isn't always a good fit for everyone, so it can require a little exploration. I'm a yoga therapist, so anytime you're looking for specific input, you want to talk to someone who does this a lot and can talk to you about what exactly is happening with you and what might be a good match for you. But even with that, it's exploration, and keeping openness and curiosity is something I always talk to my clients about. I'd say the same about exploring yoga. If you're looking for more direct guidance, work one-on-one with someone. It's a great place to start. You'll get a lot of information, and that's a lot of what I do too.

Dr. Stracks: Somebody else asked about their interest in yoga and trying to get back into it, but even the beginners' class sometimes is too painful. Do you recommend trying to work through that pain, or is it okay to dial it back to any point where it's comfortable?

Michelle Grim: There are some specific ways I look at trying to move in the setting of pain. I actually just launched a course that talks about this. It's the idea that we apply certain principles to figure out how we can move in safety. A pain-based yoga class should work with that, but pain is not necessarily what we should be listening to in order to decide how to change movement. It's about feeling safe, and we want to feel safe not only by saying “I'm safe,” which I can say to myself, but also by feeling that the body is relaxed and the breath is relaxed. Those would be my quick pointers. If you want more information, please feel free to reach out to me. There are lots of ways to apply that and find movement strategies that you could take to any class. Now that I know this strategy, I can go to any class and employ it, and it will be more therapeutic for me.

Dr. Stracks: Thanks. Any last thoughts before you go to your group?

Michelle Grim: I don't think so. I think this was really lovely, and we covered a lot of really awesome material. Thanks so much for the thoughtful questions. I can't see everyone who's here watching, but I'm so happy that we got to spend this time together, and hopefully you heard something that will inspire you in your own healing journey.

Dr. Stracks: If people want to reach out to you directly and find out more about what you do, or the kind of consultations you provide, how can they find you?

Michelle Grim: I have a website, EmbodiedHealth.co. It's .co, not .com. If you look under Services, you'll see the courses I'm currently offering, so if you're looking for a place to start that you can do on your own, with self-paced learning, I have some courses there that are more body-based. There's also a contact page on that website where you can reach out to me with any questions or set up a consult. I have a free 20-minute consult too, if you just want to connect about what's going on with you.

Dr. Stracks: Great, thanks so much for being here. It's so good to see you. We miss you in Chicago.

Michelle Grim: Thanks. It's really nice to see you too, Dr. Stracks. Good night.

Dr. Stracks: You too. I will stick around for 10 or 15 more minutes because I know there are other questions that have come in, so let me try to answer a few.

Q&A with Dr. Stracks: Sleep, Pain Flares, and Returning to Exercise

Dr. Stracks: Somebody asked about sleep. I frequently feel like TMS, or mind-body medicine principles, are relevant to sleep. There's a sleep book that I like called The Effortless Sleep Method by Sasha Stephens, and that's often what I help people move toward when they're working on sleep. Sleep is a lot about getting our bodies relaxed enough to drift off. I think sleep hygiene rules are helpful too, so I try to get people to go to bed at the same time and wake up at the same time, only be in bed if they're sleepy, not try to fight through sleep, and especially learn relaxation practices that are helpful for them. Along the lines of what we were just doing with Michelle, I also think that our narrative matters. I encourage people to start telling the story, both to themselves and to other people, about what great sleepers they are. We so often follow our narratives, whether we're talking about pain, sleep, or other health conditions. So I have people talk about how they couldn't sleep and now they can, and they learn how to do that. Those are some of the pieces I try to put in place when people are suffering from insomnia and having sleep issues. I think Sasha Stephens has a program now too that she leads people through.

The next question: “I do many of the activities that are great, but after the activity my pain level goes down to a two and then up to an eight or ten.” It's not unusual for people to find that they have more pain after an activity than they did before, and that doesn't imply that there's a physical issue going on that needs to be addressed in a physical way. It's still a mind-body issue. As we were just talking about, staying calm when that happens is an important part of getting better. If we do an activity that we like and the pain ramps up, being with it, being in that space, and calming down our brain often calms down our body as well.

Another thing I talk with people about regularly is being aware of how quickly we're jumping back into exercise. I know there's a lot in this approach about stopping physical treatments and just jumping back into exercise, but I find a lot of people really benefit from moving slowly into the things they like to do. I was talking with a patient fairly recently about this topic. She said that for years she has gotten exercise by treading water in a pool with her mom, and she did that recently and it was so painful. She said she had just done it for an hour, and I thought she was going to say she had just done it for five minutes. We had a conversation about how to move back into exercise in a reasonable way, because as we jump into things it often ramps up the soreness we get, which feels alarming. I frequently counsel people to go back maybe a little further than they think they can, and not to try to jump into a 100-mile bike ride if you haven't been riding your bike at all. That's something else to think about as you're trying to figure out how to bring exercise back into your routine.

Book Recommendations on Trauma and the Mind-Body Connection

The next question is about facial pain that's being managed well with both medication and Curable, and asks whether there's a good book about trauma and the mind-body connection, since there's been a lot of trauma in this person's life. There's some great information out there about trauma and how it works its way into the body. The two resources I like absolute best are, number one, The Last Best Cure by Donna Jackson Nakazawa. She actually has a new book out that I haven't read yet, but she's written two books about how trauma ends up in the body. The Last Best Cure is a really nice description of how she came to recognize the role that trauma played in her own health conditions, actually an autoimmune disease, and what she researched about the state of what we know about trauma, how people experience it, how it works its way into the body, and how people can heal from it.

The other one that I really love is Bessel van der Kolk's book The Body Keeps the Score. He is essentially the world's expert on trauma and the treatment of trauma, and this book is about his life's work in this area: what he's learned about it, and what people can learn about how their own experiences show up in physical ways. There are multiple chapters about what he's learned about healing trauma and what different modalities will help to do that.

Another one that's not as well known, and that I really like, is a book called Insight, with the subtitle The New Science of Post-Traumatic Growth. We've learned over time from research that over half of people who have experienced trauma will, on the other side of the trauma, say that they're better off for having gone through it, which seems kind of insane at first glance. But when you think about it a little, you can see how that growth happens. Now that we know that the majority of people have that experience, we're working on what helps push people in that direction. That book is about the research on what helps people heal from trauma and, more than just heal, thrive on the other side of these experiences. Those are some of my favorite resources about trauma and the mind-body connection.

Journaling, Emotions, and Meditation

The next question: after a meditation or an exercise like we did with Michelle, if emotions come up and sensations come up, what are the next steps? Is journal writing a good way to deal with that? Absolutely, journal writing is a great way. A lot of people will keep their journal with them when they're doing yoga or meditation. The other direction is helpful also: a lot of people will journal and then meditate and see what comes up after the meditation. Our colleague Nicole Sachs often recommends that to people.

I think it's also about being with the emotions. I mentioned earlier Sasha Stephens and her book The Effortless Sleep Method. She talks about how one of the best relaxation techniques is just to sit and be and see what comes up. I would say that's an answer we can give to this question too. We do these meditations, we sit, we do the yoga exercises, and then as emotions show up in our bodies, if we can let them be there, then oftentimes we'll feel them in our bodies, there's an emotional release, and then we're able to move on. Often that happens in 30 to 90 seconds.

I've been asking everybody during this coronavirus time: what are your hidden benefits of quarantine? One of my big ones is that I've been doing yoga online with a studio in Chapel Hill, North Carolina, called Thousand Petals Yoga, almost every morning. I get into some of the more intense poses and the emotions just start to bubble up, and I try as hard as I can to let the emotions be there, to not judge myself for having them, and to let them come out in my body, whether it's crying or trembling or shaking, and allow that to be okay. I think that's one of the best things we can do as these start to bubble up in our body: watch them, welcome them, allow them to be there, and not feel like we need to push them away.

Do Specific Therapies Work for Specific Types of Pain?

The next question is whether specific types of therapies or approaches have been shown to be helpful for specific types of pain, like facial pain, bone pain, and nerve pain. I don't know that we have mapped that precisely yet, to say that these specific approaches are good for facial pain or nerve pain. I've seen a lot of people respond to a lot of different modalities over time. I don't think we yet have the knowledge of which modality works for which specific person, which is why I encourage people to try a lot of different approaches and not necessarily think that there's one or two that are going to work for them. Different types of psychotherapy can be helpful, different kinds of movement can be helpful, and so can different kinds of journal writing and different kinds of meditation.

One of my patients, who has done really well over time, had the idea that he was going to fail quickly with as many modalities as he could get his hands on. He would try them, see if they resonated with him and felt good, and if they did he would keep them in his repertoire and go on to the next one. I don't get too wrapped up in trying to match the precise treatment with the precise person. When I'm working with somebody individually we do that as best we can, but we also know that we won't know ahead of time what's going to work best until it's tried.

Talking with a Loved One About Mind-Body Tools for Chronic Pain

The next question: how would you guide or help a loved one living with chronic pain with mind-body tools when they don't believe in them or don't want to work with them? I get this question all the time from people: how do we talk with other people about this topic? I was talking with one of my patients earlier today. I generally say that people are ready to hear this information when they're ready to hear it. When we talk with people who are near us, I'd say somewhere between 1 and 10 percent are ready to hear this right away. When you think about all the people in the world, the hundreds of thousands of people who have found their way to Curable, that's a lot of people, but the one person who lives with you may or may not be ready to hear the message.

I frequently tell people that we share our own stories and our own experiences, and we give resources to people we love and want to know about it, but ultimately it's not our responsibility to make them latch on to it. One of the things we talk about in my practice and in Curable groups is having good boundaries in place: knowing what belongs to us and what belongs to other people. We can take our story and offer it to the people who are near us who need it, and that's what we can do. Then it's their responsibility to take it up and work with it if they want to, or decide they're going to put it down. If they put it down and continue to have pain, that's their pain, and as hard as it is, we can try to let them have their pain and not make it our pain. The straighter we can keep those boundaries, and the more we know what's our responsibility and what's other people's responsibility, the easier that conversation goes. Often the more we push, the more people will push it away or pull away. So we can offer it, say, “Here's what we know,” and then allow people to take it or not, as they desire.

How Can We Increase Our Body's Feeling of Safety in Everyday Life?

A couple more questions are here, and then we'll wrap up in a few minutes. What can we do to increase our body's feeling of safety in everyday life? Some of the things Michelle was talking about: getting to know our body and learning what's going on in our body. Spend a few moments each day sitting and paying attention, coming at our bodies from a place of curiosity and from a place of kindness. I say regularly that the pain is not the enemy. The pain is just trying to push us in a direction that it wants us to go. If we can sit, even for 30 seconds, even for a couple of minutes, and notice what's going on in our body, non-judgmentally and with curiosity, we start to get a sense that the pain is not there to make us miserable. As we get a sense that we can be in our body and the pain ramps down a little, that helps to create the safety that we're looking for.

“I Definitely Have a Physical Problem. Can Mind-Body Medicine Still Reduce My Pain?”

The last question is: I definitely have a physical problem, so can you reduce the pain if there's a serious physical issue? Absolutely. We were talking about this last night in my group and in other groups that we've been running. There are all kinds of pain issues with a physical component, a psychological component, and an emotional component. In all cases, if we work on the psychological and the emotional side, we will see the pain start to reduce. What I find in working with pain is that the physical component is often much less of a piece of the overall story than the psychological and emotional components seem to be. So even if there's a physical issue there, no matter what it is, getting started with these ideas and techniques and conceptions, and moving forward with healing on an emotional, psychological, non-physical level, we often start to see the pain get better, and we often make a lot bigger strides than we think we would.

One of my patients, who has done so well over time, has gone from 200 migraines a year down to about two. She said that when she first met me she wanted to get 20 percent better. She said if she could go from 200 migraines a year down to 160, that would be an incredible win for her. She started working on this, took my class, did a mindfulness-based stress reduction class, and got a sense of how to talk with the migraine so it wasn't so scary, and she went so far past that 20 percent better. It's amazing to hear what she has done.

Closing Remarks and Next Hope for Healing Session

Those are the questions here. It's just about 6:15 in Chicago, so we'll wrap up. Thank you so much for being here with us this evening. Thank you for your attention, and thank you for being brave enough to work on your health issues in this mind-body way. It's amazingly effective. As you know, it's countercultural, but I am always inspired and touched by people who will enter into this space and say they're going to take charge of their own healing and use the tools that are available through my practice, through Curable, and through Michelle's practice. Many of you have made a little progress or a lot of progress, but as long as you are working in this area, you are going to see progress.

I am, of course, available for consultations for anybody who would like one. You can go to my website www.cormendihealth.com to make an appointment and sign up for our newsletter so we can stay in touch with you. My intention is to continue to offer these Hope for Healing sessions. In a couple of weeks we're hoping to have Dr. David Clarke, who wrote They Can't Find Anything Wrong!, and we'll continue to find people with expertise in this area that you can tap into to aid with your own healing. Thank you for being here this evening with me. I hope everybody has a great night, and I wish you continued best on your journey in this way. Have a good night, everybody, and I will see you soon.


Dr. John Stracks practices mind-body medicine via telehealth nationally and internationally. To learn more about working with Dr. Stracks or the Cormendi Health team, visit cormendihealth.com. You can find more interviews on the Cormendi Health YouTube page.

Next
Next

Hope for Healing: Dr. Stracks & David Ratner